Smith Manoeuvre Calculator 2026
Borrow back what you pay off your mortgage, invest it, and deduct the interest. See whether you'd end up ahead of simply paying your mortgage, after tax, and what return it needs.
The essentials, in plain words. New to this? Start here.
Your home and mortgage
67% of your home's value. A HELOC can only lend up to 65% in total, so borrowing back starts once the mortgage is below $390,000.
Your taxes
Each $1 of investment-loan interest saves you 31¢ in tax (31.5% marginal rate).
The investment loan and investments
After the tax refund it costs you 3.77% a year. Bank of Canada rate 2.50%, next decision Dec 9, 2026.
Includes 2.0% in dividends. Detailed lets you split it.
How you run it
After 25 years you'd be about $152k better off.
Compared with simply paying your mortgage, after paying the tax on your investment gains, if they earn 7.0% a year. It comes out ahead only if your investments earn more than 4.4% a year after fees, 2.6% below the 7.0% you entered.
- Investments you own
- $580,894
- while owing $390,000 on the HELOC
- Tax refunds
- $66,328
- about $6,508 a year by year 25
- Mortgage paid off
- On schedule
- in 25 years, same as now
- From your pocket
- $0
- the HELOC pays its own interest
- Borrowing back starts in month 14, when your mortgage drops below 65% of your home's value (the most a HELOC can lend in total).
How it works, with your numbersNew to the Smith Manoeuvre? Five steps.
- You make your usual mortgage payment of $2,214 a month. Part of it, about $764 in month 14, pays down the mortgage itself.
- Your bank lends that money straight back to you on a HELOC linked to the mortgage. You invest it in a non-registered account: stocks or ETFs that pay income. Not a TFSA or RRSP.
- Because you borrowed to earn investment income, the HELOC interest is tax-deductible (Income Tax Act 20(1)(c)). In year 5 the interest is about $1,815, which gets you about $571 back at tax time (31% of it). It grows as the HELOC grows.
- You invest the refund too, so the portfolio grows faster.
- Every month repeats. Your debt stays about the same, but bit by bit it moves from the mortgage (interest not deductible) to the HELOC (deductible), and you build a portfolio: $580,894 after 25 years.
The catch: you still owe the HELOC, and investments can fall. Keep the borrowed money separate from your own so the interest stays deductible, and talk to a tax professional before you start.
What if things go differently?
Better or worse off after 25 years, after tax, compared with just paying the mortgage.
3.0% return
−$57k
5.0% return
+$30k
7.0% return (yours)
+$152k
9.0% return
+$323k
HELOC rate 7.50%
+$74k
Your HELOC peaks at $390,000. You owe it whatever the markets do: a 30% fall would take your investments from $580,894 to $406,626, and you'd need to hold on rather than sell.
Over 25 years
The mortgage (interest not deductible) shrinks while the HELOC (deductible) grows by the same amount. The borrowed money becomes your portfolio.
Year by year
Year by year
Each row is the end of that year. The refund is for that year's interest.
| Year | Mortgage | HELOC | Deductible interest | Tax refund | Interest you paid | Dividends after tax | Investments | Ahead by (after tax) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $391,086 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| 2 | $381,767 | $8,233 | $180 | $57 | $0 | $56 | $8,330 | $71 |
| 3 | $372,023 | $17,977 | $696 | $219 | $0 | $218 | $18,455 | $352 |
| 4 | $361,836 | $28,164 | $1,243 | $391 | $0 | $395 | $29,346 | $873 |
| 5 | $351,186 | $38,814 | $1,815 | $571 | $0 | $585 | $41,057 | $1,663 |
| 6 | $340,050 | $49,950 | $2,413 | $760 | $0 | $789 | $53,649 | $2,754 |
| 7 | $328,408 | $61,592 | $3,038 | $956 | $0 | $1,009 | $67,186 | $4,182 |
| 8 | $316,237 | $73,763 | $3,692 | $1,162 | $0 | $1,245 | $81,737 | $5,984 |
| 9 | $303,511 | $86,489 | $4,375 | $1,377 | $0 | $1,499 | $97,374 | $8,202 |
| 10 | $290,206 | $99,794 | $5,090 | $1,602 | $0 | $1,773 | $114,178 | $10,880 |
| 11 | $276,296 | $113,704 | $5,836 | $1,837 | $0 | $2,066 | $132,231 | $14,067 |
| 12 | $261,753 | $128,247 | $6,617 | $2,083 | $0 | $2,381 | $151,626 | $17,816 |
| 13 | $246,548 | $143,452 | $7,434 | $2,340 | $0 | $2,720 | $172,458 | $22,184 |
| 14 | $230,651 | $159,349 | $8,287 | $2,609 | $0 | $3,084 | $194,831 | $27,233 |
| 15 | $214,031 | $175,969 | $9,180 | $2,890 | $0 | $3,475 | $218,857 | $33,030 |
| 16 | $196,654 | $193,346 | $10,113 | $3,184 | $0 | $3,895 | $244,655 | $39,648 |
| 17 | $178,487 | $211,513 | $11,088 | $3,491 | $0 | $4,346 | $272,352 | $47,166 |
| 18 | $159,493 | $230,507 | $12,108 | $3,812 | $0 | $4,830 | $302,085 | $55,668 |
| 19 | $139,635 | $250,365 | $13,174 | $4,147 | $0 | $5,349 | $333,999 | $65,248 |
| 20 | $118,872 | $271,128 | $14,289 | $4,498 | $0 | $5,907 | $368,252 | $76,004 |
| 21 | $97,165 | $292,835 | $15,455 | $4,865 | $0 | $6,506 | $405,011 | $88,044 |
| 22 | $74,471 | $315,529 | $16,673 | $5,249 | $0 | $7,149 | $444,456 | $101,485 |
| 23 | $50,743 | $339,257 | $17,947 | $5,650 | $0 | $7,838 | $486,778 | $116,451 |
| 24 | $25,936 | $364,064 | $19,279 | $6,069 | $0 | $8,578 | $532,184 | $133,078 |
| 25 | $0 | $390,000 | $20,672 | $6,508 | $0 | $9,372 | $580,894 | $151,513 |
How we calculate
No government tool models the Smith Manoeuvre, so we checked every year of each scenario against an independent month-by-month recomputation, and the mortgage side against the Government of Canada mortgage calculator.
Checked against
- Independent month-by-month recomputation of every year (no government tool exists)
- Government of Canada mortgage calculator (Financial Consumer Agency of Canada), for the mortgage side
Result: Every year of 6 scenarios matches an independent recomputation; the mortgage side matches the government mortgage calculator to the cent.
Method
- Each month: the regular mortgage payment is applied (fixed rate, compounded twice a year), the same as a normal mortgage.
- Re-borrow: the principal you just paid is re-borrowed from the HELOC and invested, up to the HELOC limit of 65% of the home’s value minus the mortgage.
- HELOC interest: charged monthly at your HELOC rate. It is added to the HELOC while there is room, otherwise you pay it out of pocket.
- Tax refund: at the end of each year, all HELOC interest charged that year times your marginal tax rate. It goes to the portfolio or the mortgage, as you choose.
- Portfolio: grows by your price growth rate; dividends, after dividend tax, are reinvested, paid onto the mortgage or kept.
- Net worth: home value minus mortgage and HELOC plus the portfolio, compared with simply paying down the same mortgage. The headline is after tax: it subtracts the capital gains tax you would owe if you sold the portfolio at the end (half of the gain over what was invested, at your marginal rate).
- Tax rate: worked out from your income and province (federal and provincial tax saved per dollar of deduction), or the rate you enter.
- Break-even return: the total yearly return (growth plus dividends) at which the after-tax result equals simply paying the mortgage, found by re-running the projection.
Rates and rules from
Not included
- Year-to-year market swings: returns are a steady assumed rate (the "What if" section shows other returns). Capital gains tax is counted as if everything were sold at the end, at today’s inclusion rate.
- The refund is credited at year end; in practice it arrives after you file, a few months later.
- Interest is only deductible if the borrowed money can be traced to income-earning investments. Mixing it with personal spending can make it non-deductible.
- Changes in HELOC or mortgage rates, home value and your tax bracket over time.
How Does the Smith Manoeuvre Work in Canada?
The Smith Manoeuvre converts non-deductible Canadian residential mortgage interest into tax-deductible investment debt. As you pay down your mortgage principal, you re-borrow the exact paid equity through a linked readvanceable HELOC to invest in income-producing assets (like Canadian dividend stocks or ETFs), making the HELOC interest legally tax-deductible against your income under CRA rules.
Step 1: Re-advancing
As you make your regular mortgage payment, the principal portion is "re-advanced" into a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC).
Step 2: Investing
The money from the HELOC is invested in income-producing assets (like dividend stocks or ETFs), making the loan interest tax-deductible.
Step 3: Tax Refunds
The tax deductions generate annual refunds, which you can use to pay down your mortgage even faster, accelerating the compounding cycle.
Step 4: Debt Conversion
Eventually, your entire non-deductible mortgage is converted into a fully deductible investment loan, improving your long-term net worth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Smith Manoeuvre legal in Canada?
Yes, the Smith Manoeuvre is 100% legal under the Canadian Income Tax Act (paragraph 20(1)(c)). The CRA permits tax deductions on interest paid for borrowed funds used to earn income from business or property.
What investments qualify for interest deductibility?
Funds must be invested in a non-registered account in assets with a reasonable expectation of producing income (such as dividend-paying stocks, ETFs, or investment properties). Borrowing to invest in registered accounts (TFSA, RRSP, FHSA) or pure capital-gain assets is not tax-deductible.